This PDF takes a look at how behavioral biases in your investment strategy may lead to very costly errors.
Successful Investor Psychology
Excerpts from TurtleTrader on how Richard Dennis handled behavioral investing:
Profits like those for Dennis came with heartburn. He was down $10 million in a single day that year before bouncing back, a roller-coaster ride that would have made mere mortals lose serious sleep. Yet Dennis cockily said that he slept like a baby during all that volatility.
His moneymaking style was about mammoth home runs and many smaller strikeouts. If there was a “secret,” he knew that you had to be able to accept losses both psychologically and physiologically. Still, 1986 was a long time ago, and memories dull when an old pro starts talking about the benefits of taking “losses.”
Dennis and Psychology
Not only was his persona different, his trading was different. Dennis read Psychology Today (no government economic or crop reports for him) to keep his emotions in check and to remind him of how over-rated intuition was in trading. He took delight in boasting, in contrast to most traders who got up early to read all they could from weather reports to daily Department of Agriculture assessments, that he stayed in bed until the last minute before getting to the exchange just as trading started.
The Psychological Reality of Being a Turtle Trader Investor
The fear of not knowing what to expect next was a constant in the Turtles lives. Turtles would get calls without explanation to increase or decrease 20 percent of their account size. They scratched their heads, wondering what was going on. Some Turtles joked that perhaps they were in a cruel psychological experiment. Others seriously considered the possibility that they were being filmed like Jim Carrey in the Truman Show.
Suggested Article: the trader Amos Hostetter Jr.
What Dennis’s Psychology Reveals
The detail about Dennis reading Psychology Today rather than crop reports or government economic data is one of the most revealing in any account of his trading approach. Most traders of his era consumed every piece of fundamental information they could find, convinced that superior information produced superior trading. Dennis consumed psychological research to understand the emotional and cognitive patterns that caused traders to make systematic errors. His competitive advantage was not better crop data. It was a clearer understanding of how the mind distorts trading decisions and a deliberate practice of countering those distortions.
The “sleep like a baby” claim during a $10 million single-day loss is not bravado. It is the description of someone who has genuinely internalized the probability framework that makes individual daily outcomes irrelevant to the assessment of whether the approach is working. A system with positive expected value over a large sample will produce days when it loses $10 million. Those days are part of the distribution. They do not indicate a broken system. The trader who loses sleep over them is the trader who cannot tell the difference between a system that is working correctly and a system that has failed. Dennis could tell the difference because he understood the math, and because he had done the psychological work required to not confuse the two.
The Turtle experience of unexplained instructions to increase or decrease account size by 20% is the pedagogical equivalent of the index card exercise. Dennis was creating uncertainty deliberately to test whether the Turtles could follow instructions without knowing the reason. The traders who could tolerate that uncertainty without demanding an explanation, who could trust the rules even when the logic was not visible, were demonstrating the psychological trait that systematic trading requires more than any other: the ability to follow a process without needing constant confirmation that the process is correct.
The behavioral biases the PDF addresses, overconfidence, loss aversion, anchoring, the disposition effect, are all pitfalls that Dennis had mapped before executing a single trade. Reading Psychology Today was not a hobby. It was preparation for understanding the enemy, which was not the market but his own psychological responses to it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did Richard Dennis read Psychology Today rather than market reports?
Because he understood that his competitive edge was not superior fundamental information but superior psychological preparation. The crop reports and government economic data were available to everyone. The understanding of how overconfidence, loss aversion, anchoring, and intuition biases distort trading decisions was less widely applied. By studying psychology while other traders studied fundamentals, Dennis was building a mental framework that helped him avoid the systematic errors those traders were making.
How could Dennis sleep through a $10 million single-day loss?
Because he understood probability well enough to know that a single day’s loss does not indicate whether a system is working correctly. A positive-expectation system will produce large losing days as a normal feature of its distribution. The trader who cannot sleep through those days is confusing noise with signal, treating the individual outcome as meaningful when only the distribution over a large sample is meaningful. Dennis had internalized this distinction deeply enough that the daily volatility did not disturb him.
What was the psychological lesson of unexplained instructions to the Turtles?
That following a process without needing constant justification is the essential psychological skill of systematic trading. The Turtles who needed to understand the reason for every instruction before complying were revealing the same psychological pattern that causes retail traders to override their own rules when they cannot immediately see why a rule applies to the current situation. The trader who can follow the rules without needing confirmation is the trader who can sustain a systematic approach through its difficult periods.
Trend Following Systems
Want to learn more and start trading trend following systems? Start here.
