It is very important to have stock options trading strategies in mind if you wish to be a successful turtle trader. Gerd Gigerenzer has the following to say about the heuristics of navigating the unknown.
It is very important to have stock options trading strategies in mind if you wish to be a successful turtle trader. Gerd Gigerenzer has the following to say about the heuristics of navigating the unknown.
Reading works from people such as Gerd Gigerenzer may help you to become more successful at trading.
“What interests me is the question of how humans learn to live with uncertainty. Before the scientific revolution determinism was a strong ideal. Religion brought about a denial of uncertainty, and many people knew that their kin or their race was exactly the one that God had favored. They also thought they were entitled to get rid of competing ideas and the people that propagated them. How does a society change from this condition into one in which we understand that there is this fundamental uncertainty? How do we avoid the illusion of certainty to produce the understanding that everything, whether it be a medical test or deciding on the best cure for a particular kind of cancer, has a fundamental element of uncertainty?” — Gerd Gigerenzer, Edge.org
Gigerenzer’s Framework Applied to Trading
Gigerenzer’s central research finding is that in environments of genuine uncertainty, simple heuristics outperform complex models. This is counterintuitive and directly contradicts the assumption that more information, more computation, and more sophisticated models always produce better decisions. Gigerenzer’s work demonstrates empirically that this is not the case in uncertain environments — which is precisely what financial markets are.
The distinction he draws is between risk and uncertainty. Risk is a situation where all possible outcomes and their probabilities are known. Rolling a die is a risk: six possible outcomes, each with probability one-sixth. Uncertainty is a situation where not all outcomes are known and their probabilities cannot be reliably estimated. Financial markets are uncertain, not risky, in this technical sense. The next major market event — a sovereign debt crisis, a pandemic, a technological disruption — is not in the probability distribution derived from historical data because it has not happened before in that form.
In risky environments, complex models with many parameters outperform simple rules because the extra parameters capture genuine regularities in the data. In uncertain environments, the opposite is true. Complex models overfit to historical regularities that do not persist. Simple heuristics that ignore most of the available information and focus on the one or two most important signals outperform complex models because they are more robust to the future being different from the past.
This is the scientific foundation for the simplicity of systematic trend following rules. A rule that buys when price exceeds the 20-week high and sells when it falls below the 10-week low ignores almost all available information about the underlying market. It does not process earnings, economic indicators, management quality, competitive position, or macroeconomic forecasts. It reads one signal and acts on it. Gigerenzer’s research says that in uncertain environments, this approach will outperform models that incorporate all available information, because the additional information adds noise rather than signal and the complex model becomes brittle to environmental change while the simple rule remains robust.
Gigerenzer also challenges the assumption that ignoring information is irrational. Conventional investment analysis treats the gathering and processing of more information as always superior. Gigerenzer’s research demonstrates that the value of additional information depends on how it is used and in what environment. In uncertain environments, additional information often reduces decision quality by providing more material for confirmation bias, overconfidence, and the illusion of understanding. The trader who acts on one robust signal and ignores the rest of the noise is not being irrational. They are applying the correct heuristic for the uncertain environment in which they operate.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Gigerenzer’s key distinction between risk and uncertainty?
Risk describes situations where all possible outcomes and their probabilities are known, as in games of chance. Uncertainty describes situations where outcomes and probabilities are not fully knowable, as in financial markets. Most financial risk management frameworks treat markets as risky in the technical sense, using historical probability distributions to estimate future outcomes. Gigerenzer argues this is the wrong framework for genuine uncertainty, where the future will produce outcomes not well-represented in historical data.
Why do simple heuristics outperform complex models in uncertain environments?
Because complex models with many parameters fit historical data closely but overfit to regularities that do not persist into the future. When the environment changes — as markets regularly do — the complex model’s parameters no longer match the new environment and performance deteriorates. Simple heuristics with few parameters are less precisely fitted to historical data but more robust to environmental change because they capture only the most persistent structural features rather than transient historical patterns.
How does Gigerenzer’s work relate to systematic trend following rules?
Directly. A trend following rule that uses three to five parameters to define entry, exit, and position size is exactly the type of simple, robust heuristic that Gigerenzer’s research identifies as superior in uncertain environments. The rule ignores most available information and focuses on price movement, the one signal that directly reflects the market’s aggregate judgment about all available information. The simplicity is not a limitation. It is the source of the approach’s robustness across diverse market conditions.
Trend Following Systems
Want to learn more and start trading trend following systems? Start here.
