There are a few TurtleTraders out there, ones trained by Richard Dennis, that failed miserably and have now tried to become “gurus” (with little success). These gurus can make trying to understand the real turtle story difficult. Where is the truth? There is only one objective accounting of the Turtle story start to finish including the good the bad and the ugly. That story is found in the book “The Complete TurtleTrader”. The Turtles were taught timeless lessons. Their rules work. However, if you want to trade like a successful turtle you must first find out why some Turtles failed.
Questions? Ask.
The Guru Pattern Among Failed Turtles
The path from failed trader to trading guru is well-worn and predictable. It begins with a track record that cannot support raising institutional capital. It continues with a pivot toward retail education, where the Turtle brand generates enough recognition to attract customers who will pay for courses, seminars, and newsletters. The regulatory record of some failed Turtles, documented in NFA enforcement actions, shows the specific form this pivot takes: using the Turtle name and association with Richard Dennis to market trading products while obscuring actual performance results.
The failed Turtle guru’s essential problem is the evidentiary standard. Jerry Parker’s actual track record at Chesapeake Capital, Liz Cheval’s actual track record at EMC, and Paul Rabar’s actual track record at Rabar Market Research are all publicly available audited performance documents. These are the standards against which any Turtle-adjacent trading educator should be measured. The successful Turtles do not need to sell courses about how to trade like a Turtle. Their trading results speak for them. The ones who sell the courses are typically the ones whose trading results do not.
The rules themselves are timeless. The 20-day breakout entry, the N-based position sizing, the trailing stop exit, and the portfolio diversification across uncorrelated global markets all continue to work for the practitioners who apply them consistently. The Turtle experiment did not fail. The specific Turtles who could not follow the rules consistently failed. That distinction is the most important thing to understand before attempting to trade like a successful Turtle.
The Complete TurtleTrader is the only source that documents both the successful and unsuccessful Turtles with equal completeness. Other accounts, particularly those written by failed Turtles, naturally emphasize their own role and contributions while omitting or minimizing the evidence of their failures and regulatory problems. The independent accounting that includes the full picture, the wins, the losses, the NFA fines, and the casino junket proposals, is the foundation for an accurate understanding of what the Turtle experiment actually proved and what it did not.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can you distinguish legitimate Turtle-trained traders from failed Turtle gurus?
By looking at their actual audited trading track records rather than their self-promotional materials. Successful Turtle graduates have multi-decade audited performance records that are available through regulatory disclosure documents. Failed Turtle gurus typically offer courses, seminars, and newsletters rather than audited track records, because the audited track records would undermine the marketing claims. The NFA requires audited performance disclosure for registered commodity trading advisors; any Turtle-associated trading educator who is not a registered CTA or who does not provide audited performance documentation warrants scrutiny.
Why do the Turtle rules still work despite failed Turtles claiming they do not?
Because the rules capture a structural feature of markets rather than a period-specific anomaly: the tendency of prices to trend for extended periods due to the behavioral biases documented in behavioral finance research. Loss aversion, herding, and anchoring continue to produce the sustained directional price movements that trend following captures. The failed Turtles who claimed that trend following stopped working were describing their own inability to follow the rules consistently, not a structural change in market dynamics.
Why is The Complete TurtleTrader the only reliable source on the Turtle story?
Because it is the only account that covers both successful and unsuccessful Turtles with equal completeness, includes documentary evidence rather than relying exclusively on self-reported accounts, and was written by an independent author without a financial interest in presenting any particular Turtle’s story favorably. Accounts written by participants, particularly unsuccessful ones, have inherent selection bias toward emphasizing favorable details and minimizing unfavorable ones. The Complete TurtleTrader includes the NFA fines, the failed funds, the casino junket proposals, and the departed Turtles alongside the billion-dollar managers.
Trend Following Systems
Want to learn more and start trading trend following systems? Start here.
