First time visitor? Click here. | Login | Register

Send to Friend

FromTo

Captcha
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.

Send to Friend from TurtleTrader

Trend Following Debate

Michael Covel (May 26, 2005)

There is a small minority who vociferously question trend following's validity. They believe that prediction is an absolute:

So, in other words, you trade according to a system the signals of which are not associated with whether price will move both in the right direction and to a certain minimum extent after the trader has committed to a prospective entry? Good luck. You're going to need it.

This is correct. Trend followers can never have knowledge of some minimum extent move after an entry. How could anyone give a minimum?

In the book Trend Following the notion that you can predict anything is addressed head on, but a recent discussion post also frames the issue correctly:

Technical Analysis is attacked for what people wish it could do. Trend following like any form of technical analysis is a risk management tool, not a price prediction tool. Once again, this is why [anyone]'s demand for a predictive model using trends is downright silly. There is no such model and that is not inconsistent with the fact that trend following is a valid form of technical analysis.

In discussing the downsides of the prediction mindset, another trader offered:

Although I'm sure there are folks making money by predicting price (perhaps you are one of them), I've never actually met one. All the good traders I know use probability instead. Personally I didn't start turning regular profits until I got rid of the prediction framework. Also, there was a long time where I thought I surely wasn't predicting price, but in fact I was [attempting to do so]. These things are part of the long and painful growing process [to overcome]. The only way to avoid it...[is to think in terms of a]...probability framework from the beginning.

amazon.com

Complete TurtleTrader
Order now!

The Complete Turtle story. Legend, lessons & results.

amazon.com

Trend Following
Order now!

Now available: the new expanded edition. Order online today.

Get started

If you would like to find articles by category simply choose from the list below.

  • Market Wizards Jim Simons

    The advantage scientists bring into the game is less their mathematical or computational skills than their ability to think scientifically. They are less likely to accept an apparent winning strategy that might be a mere statistical fluke. (Read more)

Meet Michael Covel

Blog | Read bio